Best Batting-Wicketkeeper

oh.. dear or dear... what are you saying krisdy...
Dhoni is the best wicket keeper batsmen!...oh..are you mad..
 what  hapened  to Kumara sangakkara and Adem Gilchrist...
i think they are the best so far we seen...
of cource... Gilly.. is close to retire , but you cant discount him...
and i think he(gilly) will play better than dhoni..after his fifties..
same about the sangakkara as wel..he is just 28, and you did not seen his best..you..will see sangakkara's best in icc champion ship
and world cup...
i think even Dinesh Ramdin is better than dhoni....
Dhoni is basically  a sloger.. nothing mor than that..slouch  with the glowes... he may scorea feve in the sub continant... but he will never make big runs in Australia or NZ...or even in england..
Gilly and Sangakkara have made big runs all over the world..



Edited by neranja

Adam Gilchrist For Sure

My rating goes for Dhoni along with Sangakkara, coz even with such destructive talent they both have theses lads play to finish the game off.

In the Eng vs Ind match , thought Dhoni didn't do well , but his approach was nice and was ready to adept to the situation.

More than his hitting abilities I like his temperment and cricketing brain.

Certainly not Kamran Akmal. Let the ball go through wice. 5 extra runs. This is pretty much where he left off in England. At least he caught the edge though!

What are Pakistan's other options for wicket keeper?

Originally posted by fishcake14 Certainly not Kamran Akmal. Let the ball go through wice. 5 extra runs. This is pretty much where he left off in England. At least he caught the edge though! What are Pakistan's other options for wicket keeper?

well that was due to un even bounce.the ball kept low and wasnt really his fault i guess.Sangakkara also left may deliveries today,and we'll also have to see how gilly perform in Sub continnent pitches.

Are they good as Rashid latif or Moin Khan?

Pak's other real keeping options are,A.Zulqarnain haider,  Humayun Farhat brother of current opener Imran, and Kamran akmal's younger brother who is very talented keeper/bat. Then there is Moin khan who has not yet retired!

Edited by inzamam329

I watched CS Baugh today. Not all that great. Ridley Jacobs is still a better choice.

I forgot he retired. Thought he was kicked out because of bad form.

Originally posted by dhoniisbest My rating for Dhoni has slightly decreased, because of his bad form at the moment. About the Eng vs. India match, he was just trying to end it fast as he could. I don't blame him for getting out.

dont worry , Dhoni's blitz is due in the next two matches

Originally posted by Sledger Originally posted by DRAVID FAN I watched CS Baugh today. Not all that great. Ridley Jacobs is still a better choice. Deryk Murray is still breathing too....

I dont know Deryk Murray but Baugh is is bad .Ramdin is a better keper for sure

Originally posted by MP12 I'd say Gilchrist only because i haven't seen very much of Dhoni. I might change my mind when i see him play Australia in the Champions Trophy and World Cup

Is it , really you missed world one of the most destructive batsman exploits till now then.

Originally posted by MP12 i've heard about him and know quite about him aswell but i haven't seen him in the flesh.

humm he is a sensible cricketer like symmonds , plays according to situation. Can keep head dwon when required and can blast any bowler. He is the wk with highest Score 183 not out

I just don't want to judge him untill i see him in a game or on tv

I dont think he will, I think he's a one trick pony, sometimes it pulls off for him, sometimes it doesnt.